Are Your Own Gender Biases Holding You Back?
The Complete Lawyer
Our doubts are traitors, and make us lose the good we oft might win by fearing to attempt.
At least once every year I offer a coaching group for women lawyers on rainmaking. During the first call, each participant explains what she hopes to accomplish through the group and describes the obstacles currently impeding her marketing success.
The “universal” and primary obstacle is invariably some variation on this theme: marketing requires exaggeration of one’s skills, shameless self-promotion and aggressiveness. Because of this, it is something that comes easily to men but is offensive to women.
Is Your Perception Of Marketing As A "Male" Activity Causing You To Underestimate Your Own Potential?
Given these beliefs, it’s not surprising that these women are not out making rain. But these convictions are actually gender stereotypes. Although many women lawyers recognize the influence of female stereotypes on the behavior of men, they often fail to see the extent to which they hold similar beliefs—or how these stereotypes become an internal glass ceiling.
To the extent to which we hold stereotyped beliefs about men and women, these beliefs lead us not only to expect gender-related differences in how people will behave, but also can cause us to perceive sex differences even when they are not present. Perceptions of a task as stereotypically masculine can affect people’s assessments of their own skills and potential for success. Could it be that your perception of marketing as a “male” activity is causing you to underestimate your own skill and potential?
This is a crucial issue to address since marketing is among the biggest stumbling blocks to career advancement for women lawyers. Every lawyer, whether in private practice, in-house or in government needs to find work that needs doing and adds value. There are only two bases for job security in today’s economy, both of which are central to marketing: 1) your social capital; and 2) your ability to add value to your client or organization.
Why So Few Women Rainmakers?
Certainly in law firms, the ticket to power and leadership is your book of business. Successful marketing is not sufficient to attain leadership in a firm, but it absolutely is necessary.
Most efforts to explain the relative paucity of women rainmakers attribute this to:
The exclusion of women from informal “old boys” networks which deprives them of connections to clients
The "Good Old Boy" Network Is Far Less Important Today
This discomfort is an outgrowth of gender stereotypes combined with the absence of role models and mentors. What many women lawyers perceive as marketing is really the exclusive practice of roughly 10 percent of lawyers. These “natural” rainmakers are particularly visible because they frequently bring in a disproportionately large amount of a firm’s business. Furthermore, the same extroverted, charismatic personalities that have made them effective marketers, also make them especially visible internally. They are in the spotlight, and therefore, without advisors to indicate otherwise, are perceived to be models of how marketing should be done.
In fact, not only is it the case that perhaps 90 percent of lawyers are not “natural” rainmakers, it is also true that the ways many rainmakers historically brought in business are rarely effective anymore. The personal loyalty (otherwise known as the “Good Old Boy” network) these rainmakers cultivated years ago play a much smaller role in outside counsel selection today.
A Realistic View Of Marketing Through A Non-Gendered Lens
If you suspend all of your beliefs about what effective marketing looks like you can create a space in your mind for a very different picture. Of course you already know that your prospect or client has many attorneys from which to choose. It can’t just be great legal work that makes the difference, since there are many brilliant attorneys. So what do you have to do in order to have someone choose you to be their lawyer?
Most fundamentally you must demonstrate that you understand the client’s goals and needs and that you can help them succeed in accomplishing their objectives.
Become The CEO Of Your Own Career
William Bridges* points out that in today’s free agent economy, each of us must think of ourselves as the CEO of our own career. He suggests that you imagine how your client might answer the following questions after you’ve delivered your service:
How have I or my situation improved since You & Co. came in the door?
Laurie -- A Model Of How To Add Value
Laurie, a Washington, D. C. attorney in a large firm, is an exceptional model of adding value. Long before becoming an equity partner in her firm she began establishing relationships with women in-house counsel. As an active member in the Women’s Bar Association she had regular contact with women lawyers working in a variety of settings and she developed and maintained relationships with people she liked.
During her frequent lunches with these women, they would share their work challenges. One acquaintance was the only woman in senior management in her company and Laurie listened compassionately to her stories of exclusion, inequitable pay and limited access to the CEO. Laurie’s suggestions about possible approaches to challenging situations were often very helpful to this in-house attorney. By the time this woman became the General Counsel, she felt she’d already benefited significantly from Laurie’s counsel without ever having hired her as her lawyer. She’d come to know Laurie’s incisiveness and good judgment; she’d experienced Laurie’s genuine interest in understanding her goals and needs as well as her reliability and responsiveness. When faced with a significant problem likely to result in litigation, Laurie immediately came to mind. Besides, as a woman GC in a male-dominated industry, she preferred to give her business to a woman—as long as she believed that that woman was the best attorney to do the work.
Eleanor Had Become Frightened Of Winding Up Like The Partner Next Door
Perhaps you’re saying to yourself that you can see how you might demonstrate value, but how can you get access to decision-makers in order to market your services to them?
A woman lawyer in a small Southern firm asked me to coach her when she became panicked about her future at her firm. Her excellent work had always been recognized in her evaluations. But she’d gotten all of her work from one partner and he’d just left the firm. Her office was adjacent to that of a senior “service” partner who’d taken to sitting at his desk in darkness, doing nothing. He had no business of his own and as younger men entered the firm they had no interest in keeping him busy. Never having needed to market before, he saw himself as too old to start now. He’d simply given up.
Eleanor had become frightened of winding up like the partner next door. She believed that marketing meant going to networking events, handing out business cards and “chit-chatting” with strangers. There was nothing more that she dreaded than networking. If this is what was required to succeed, her career was doomed.
Networking Is About Generosity And Thoughtfulness, Not ?Hawking Your Wares?
In my experience, Eleanor’s misperception of networking is not unique to her. But why would anyone who gave it serious thought conclude that handing out business cards to people with whom you briefly talk about nothing of substance would result in business?
Networking is about establishing and nurturing relationships for the purpose of mutually exchanging knowledge, support, recommendations, referrals, information and introductions.
Most fundamentally, networking is about generosity and thoughtfulness. If you maintain a marketing mindset, than any situation in which you meet people is a networking opportunity. When introduced to someone, your natural interest and curiosity should lead you. Your goal is to get to know someone well enough that you will be in a position to be helpful to them. Help need not be limited to legal assistance.
Once Eleanor’s perception of networking changed, so did her behavior. She began arranging personal meetings with firm clients, listening to their concerns and demonstrating how they might benefit from her solutions. New matters increasingly came directly to her. Eleanor is now an equity partner at her firm—and a member of the management committee.
The More You Unselfishly Create And Sustain Relationships, The Greater Your Social Capital
Since everyone is time-starved you won’t be trying to develop a relationship with everyone you meet. A clear picture of your target market will provide a focus for networking. It’s also important to genuinely enjoy interacting with a prospective network member since these are relationships that are cultivated with care over time. No “one night stands” here.
Your social capital is your ability to draw on a network of relationships, including colleagues, other professionals, former clients and other contacts. The more you unselfishly create and sustain relationships, the greater your social capital. As your network expands, the distance between you and prospective clients decreases. With patience and persistence, access to that decision-maker is just one or two connections away.
Marketing Is A Long-Term Investment -- Put Aside Your Doubts And Just Try
The most realistic obstacle to marketing for many women lawyers is work/life conflict. Especially if you have young children and have not negotiated an equitable sharing of household responsibilities with your partner, you may not be able to imagine how you can find time for marketing.
However, there are reasons for optimism. One woman attorney I coached recognized that the school her child attends is filled with children whose parents are lawyers. Every school event was a marketing opportunity. A woman litigator I coached met a client on a grocery check-out line. You never know where you may meet a prospect—so try to always put your best foot forward.
Odds are many of your prospects are women struggling with similar work/life challenges. They don’t want to go to client dinners any more than you do – but lunches might work. Why not invite a client and her family to attend a family-oriented event with you and your household?
There may be limits to how much time you can realistically devote to marketing. But if you consistently spend even five percent more time now than before in marketing activities, the seeds you plant will eventually bear fruit. Marketing is a long-term investment. Put aside your doubts and just try. Your efforts will be rewarded.
*Bridges, William, Creating You & Co: Learn to Think Like the Ceo of Your Own Career, Cambridge, MA, Perseus Books, 1997, p.134.
Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., is the founder of Lawyers Life Coach LLC, a firm providing professional development, career, business development and executive coaching services to attorneys and consultation to legal employers. Known for her expertise on issues of particular concern to women lawyers, her email newsletter, Beyond the Billable Hour™ has been reprinted by 25 different bar association publications and many other print and electronic legal publications. She has addressed the ABA, NAWL, NALP, the ABA Commission on Women in the Profession and numerous state and women's bar associations. She earned her Ph.D. in Psychology from the University of Rochester, received her certification in coaching from the MentorCoach™ program and currently serves on their faculty.